About Brother's Pizza

NY Style Pizza and Italian Food Since 1998

A Long History of Delicious Food

History of Brother's Pizza

Brother’s Pizza is a small, family-owned Italian restaurant that has been around for more than 16 years. Owner Benny (Biagio Scamardelli) and his wife are both of Southern Italian descent and brought their family to America in 1994. After working in a pizza shop for four years, Benny took over Brother’s Pizza in 1998.

What Makes Brother's Pizza The Best?

Since 1998

Our Growth And Locations

We’re located in Hanover, McSherrystown, Gettysburg/Bonneauville, and York. The McSherrystown location opened first in 1998 and it is a small and friendly store. The second location was in Hanover and opened in October 2008 and was recently purchased by Tony and Nicole Giron. Our Gettysburg location joined the family in June 2013 and is owned by Andrea and Lea Rinaldi. Andrea is of Italian origin as well. Benny recently opened the Spring Grove restaurant to bring the Brother’s Pizza quality to the York area.


Located on York St. only minutes away from downtown Hanover.


Our very first location. Conveniently located in the Main Street Plaza.


Located in Bonneauville, minutes away from the heart of Gettysburg.


Located just off Route 30, less than 2 miles from downtown York.


NY Style pizza with all the toppings, by the slice.

Italian Food

Authentic Italian meals made to order.


Burgers and subs for lunch and dinner. Add sides.


Small plates and starters for any appetite.

Made to Order Hot Pizza & Homemade Italian Food

Experience Our Extensive Menus

The Brother’s Pizza family is dedicated to bringing high-quality Italian food to your table. Our pizza dough and tomato sauce are homemade daily, and the pizzas are hand-tossed. This provides you with a savory and authentic pizza experience!

Feeding you and your family shouldn’t come at a high cost. At Brother’s Pizza, our menu is chock-full of competitively priced food. Your wallet will always be happy. Even better, we are constantly having coupons available, so check them out often!