NY Style Pizza & Italian Food

  • Dine-In
  • Carry-Out
  • Dine-In
  • Carry-Out
DISCOVER OUR MENUS

The Best Pizza in York and Adams County

Good Things Come to Those Who Order Brother's Pizza!

Ready to Order? Call Us!

Brother’s Pizza is a small, family-owned Italian restaurant that has been around for more than 16 years. Owner Benny (Biagio Scamardelli) and his wife are both of Southern Italian descent and brought their family to America in 1994. After working in a pizza shop for four years, Benny took over Brother’s Pizza in 1998.

Why is Brother's Pizza the Best?

  • NY Style Pizza & Authentic Italian Food
  • Fresh, Quality Ingredients
  • Made to Order Entrees
  • Local Delivery, Dine-In & Carry-Out
MENUS
Coupons
Pizza

NY Style pizza with all the toppings, by the slice.

Italian Food

Authentic Italian meals made to order.

Sandwiches

Burgers, subs and wraps for lunch and dinner.

Appetizers

Small plates and salads for any appetite.

Homemade Italian Food & NY Style Pizza Since 1998

4 Locations to Order Pizza & Entrees

Hanover
Menu

Located on York St. only minutes away from downtown Hanover.

(717) 632-0926

VIEW MENU

McSherrystown
Menu

Our very first location. Conveniently located in the Main Street Plaza.

(717) 630-8945

VIEW MENU

Gettysburg
Menu

Located in Bonneauville, minutes away from the heart of Gettysburg.

(717) 398-2676

VIEW MENU

York
Menu

Located in Spring Grove, less than 2 miles from downtown York.

(717) 739-8845

VIEW MENU

Italian Food Specialties

More than Pizza

Brother’s Pizza is more than pizza! Come in for your favorite Italian entrees, sandwiches, subs, burgers, appetizers and side dishes.

Special Offers

Get Discounts on Delivery & Carry-Out

Download coupons for everyday deals on pizza, dinner, subs and wraps.

View Coupons
Discount

Coupons

Pizzas, Entrees, Subs
& Wraps

View Coupons

Brother's Pizza Customer Reviews

Read what verified customers have to say about Brother’s Pizza authentic Italian food and gourmet pizza.

Randall Meinsen
Randall Meinsen
December 8, 2022.
Victor Hugo Torres Lopez
Victor Hugo Torres Lopez
December 1, 2022.
Spencer Wolfe
Spencer Wolfe
October 31, 2022.
The LOVLEY server girl named jewel made my experience a 10/10
Peanut
Peanut
October 19, 2022.
Ashley Hufnagel
Ashley Hufnagel
October 16, 2022.
The food here is always fast and delicious. I’d highly recommend eating here.
James Feezer
James Feezer
October 12, 2022.
The food is always top notch here. The pizza is really good some say it the best around, who am I to disagree. I like the subs never disappointed prices are very good for the quality.
Linda Stitely
Linda Stitely
September 24, 2022.
Tiffany Kopp
Tiffany Kopp
September 13, 2022.
We ordered (Door Dash) Food and decided to take it back because it was terrible, frozen shrimp Alfredo(nasty), fries cold,etc. food back and they said the food wasn't theirs. My husband had the receipt in hand. He was treated poorly and we ended up hungry and lost almost 50.00